Evaluations

Rubric v1 · 5 dims · LLM-as-judge (DeepSeek). Each row is an analysis scored 1–5 per dim.

Cost & usage

Total spend

$0.2709

n = 116

Avg per analysis

$0.00234

Avg latency

11411ms

↑ / ↓ tokens

223.6k / 191.4k

Excludes the streaming /api/analyze path — usage isn't reachable from that flow (limitation, not a bug). Includes batch evals + scenario runs + re-runs.

Average by prompt version

key	n	overall	Specificity	Safety	Actionability	Domain correctness	Completeness
v1	49	4.58	4.61	4.04	4.61	4.92	4.71
v2	52	4.41	4.54	3.98	4.54	4.81	4.17
v3	34	4.58	4.71	4.00	4.71	4.79	4.68

Average by output language

key	n	overall	Specificity	Safety	Actionability	Domain correctness	Completeness
en	67	4.60	4.72	4.07	4.72	4.91	4.60
zh	68	4.42	4.50	3.94	4.50	4.78	4.40

Individual evaluations (135)

v2zh3.60[Eval][v2][zh] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:09:16 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 3Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 3
Solid incident response with good specificity and domain correctness, but safety could be improved by adding safer-first alternatives, and completeness is hindered by placeholders in the postmortem.
v2zh4.20[Eval][v2][zh] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:08:55 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with concrete evidence and actionable steps; minor gaps in command specificity and postmortem completeness.
v2zh4.40[Eval][v2][zh] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:08:39 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
A thorough and well-structured incident response with strong specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor improvements could include more explicit time ranges in commands and safer-first alternatives for mitigations.
v2en4.60[Eval][v2][en] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:08:18 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent incident response with high specificity, actionability, and domain correctness; minor safety and completeness gaps prevent a perfect score.
v2en4.60[Eval][v2][en] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:08:02 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity, actionability, and domain correctness. Minor safety concern and placeholder gaps in postmortem prevent a perfect score.
v2en4.60[Eval][v2][en] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:07:41 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor gaps in postmortem placeholders and a slight safety concern with the manual warm script.
v1zh4.20[Eval][v1][zh] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:07:21 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 3Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
A thorough and well-structured incident response with strong domain correctness and completeness, though minor improvements in specificity and safety would elevate it further.
v1zh4.80[Eval][v1][zh] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:07:03 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor improvement: consider safer-first alternative before increasing DB pool size.
v1zh4.40[Eval][v1][zh] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:06:42 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
A thorough and well-structured incident response with concrete evidence and actionable steps, scoring high across all dimensions.
v1en4.20[Eval][v1][en] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:06:26 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 3Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
A thorough and well-structured incident response with strong specificity and domain correctness. Minor improvements in safety (safer DB scaling) and actionability (script details) would make it excellent.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:06:09 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety concern with manual warm-up script risk, but overall outstanding.
v1en4.40[Eval][v1][en] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/3/2026, 12:05:51 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
A thorough and well-structured incident response with strong specificity, safety, and domain correctness. Minor improvements could include more detailed commands and a pre-written warm script.
v3zh4.20[Eval][v3][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:05:35 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with clear root cause and actionable steps. Minor gaps in specificity (relative time window) and completeness (missing timeline details) prevent a perfect score.
v3zh4.20[Eval][v3][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:05:17 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong incident response with high specificity, safety, and domain correctness. Minor improvements in actionability and completeness would make it excellent.
v3zh4.80[Eval][v3][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:05:01 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v3en4.40[Eval][v3][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:04:43 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
A thorough and well-structured incident response that scores highly across all dimensions, with minor room for improvement in specificity and actionability of some commands.
v3en4.80[Eval][v3][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:04:22 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety improvement possible but overall outstanding.
v3en4.80[Eval][v3][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:04:02 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety improvement possible for hot-patch step.
v2zh4.60[Eval][v2][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:03:40 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and actionability; minor safety and completeness gaps.
v2zh4.60[Eval][v2][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:03:26 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent response with high specificity, actionability, and domain correctness; minor safety and completeness gaps prevent a perfect score.
v2zh4.60[Eval][v2][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:03:10 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong response with high specificity and actionability; minor safety and completeness gaps prevent a perfect score.
v2en4.20[Eval][v2][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:02:52 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with clear root cause and actionable steps; minor gaps in specificity and completeness due to placeholders.
v2en4.20[Eval][v2][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:02:32 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with clear root cause identification and actionable steps. Minor improvements in specificity and completeness would make it excellent.
v2en4.20[Eval][v2][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:02:11 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with high specificity and domain correctness. Minor improvements could include filling placeholders and adding time ranges to commands.
v1zh4.00[Eval][v1][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:01:52 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 4
A strong incident response with specific commands and clear mitigation. Minor improvements: replace placeholders for full copy-pasteability and adjust severity to SEV1.
v1zh4.40[Eval][v1][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:01:37 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
A strong, well-structured incident response with clear root cause analysis and actionable steps. Minor improvements in command specificity and actionability would make it excellent.
v1zh4.00[Eval][v1][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:01:21 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with clear evidence and actionable steps. Minor improvements in command specificity and severity classification would make it excellent.
v1en4.20[Eval][v1][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:01:03 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with clear root cause analysis and actionable steps. Minor improvements in specificity and completeness would make it excellent.
v1en4.40[Eval][v1][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:00:47 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
A thorough and well-structured incident response that is specific, safe, actionable, correct, and complete. Minor improvements could include fully copy-pasteable commands and explicit safer-first alternatives.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/3/2026, 12:00:29 AM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v3zh4.20[Eval][v3][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/3/2026, 12:00:01 AM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with clear evidence and actionable steps. Minor improvements could include more precise time ranges in commands and fewer placeholders in the postmortem.
v3zh4.80[Eval][v3][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:59:44 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety improvement possible by adding safer-first alternatives.
v3zh4.20[Eval][v3][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:59:29 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with concrete evidence and actionable steps, slightly held back by minor placeholders and a few less-immediate actions.
v3en4.80[Eval][v3][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:59:11 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety concern with destructive fallback but overall outstanding.
v3en4.80[Eval][v3][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:58:53 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor improvement: consider adding a shorter timeout (e.g., 8s) as a mitigation.
v3en4.20[Eval][v3][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:58:37 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with clear evidence and actionable steps; minor gaps in specificity and completeness prevent top scores.
v2zh4.00[Eval][v2][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:58:20 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 3
Strong response with high specificity and domain correctness; safety and actionability are good but could be improved with more precise time ranges and fully filled postmortem sections.
v2zh4.60[Eval][v2][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:58:07 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent incident response with high specificity, actionability, and domain correctness. Minor gaps in completeness (postmortem placeholders) and safety (acceptable risk in mitigation).
v2zh4.20[Eval][v2][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:57:50 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor improvements: add time ranges to all commands, fill in postmortem placeholders, and provide more detailed risk descriptions.
v2en4.80[Eval][v2][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:57:33 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 5Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent response with high specificity, safety, actionability, and domain correctness; completeness slightly reduced due to placeholder sections in postmortem draft.
v2en4.20[Eval][v2][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:57:17 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with high specificity, safety, and domain correctness. Minor improvements could include fully fleshing out the postmortem and adding more detail on enabling the circuit breaker.
v2en4.80[Eval][v2][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:57:02 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1zh4.20[Eval][v1][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:56:45 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with clear evidence and actionable steps. Minor improvements could include more precise commands and fuller postmortem sections.
v1zh4.80[Eval][v1][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:56:32 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1zh4.80[Eval][v1][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:56:19 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety concern with circuit breaker activation but rollback provided.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:56:04 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1en4.60[Eval][v1][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:55:50 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and actionability; minor safety concern and placeholder in postmortem draft.
v1en4.60[Eval][v1][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:55:37 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor placeholder in postmortem timeline prevents a perfect 5 in completeness.
v3zh4.20[Eval][v3][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:55:22 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 5
A strong, well-structured incident response with clear evidence and actionable steps. Minor improvements: add time ranges to commands, ensure all rollback commands are explicit, and calibrate severity to SEV2.
v3zh4.60[Eval][v3][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:55:08 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 5
Excellent response with high specificity and actionability; minor severity misclassification prevents a perfect score.
v3zh4.60[Eval][v3][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:54:53 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 5
Excellent response with high specificity and actionability. Minor severity misclassification prevents perfect domain correctness score.
v3en4.60[Eval][v3][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:54:38 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, actionability, and completeness. Minor issue in severity classification and a slight distraction with fast-json-stringify, but overall very strong.
v3en4.60[Eval][v3][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:54:23 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 5
Excellent response with high specificity, actionability, and completeness. Minor safety concern and severity misclassification prevent a perfect score.
v3en4.80[Eval][v3][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:54:09 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety concern on scaling down HPA but overall outstanding.
v2zh4.40[Eval][v2][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:53:54 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and actionability; minor issues in severity classification and postmortem completeness.
v2zh4.60[Eval][v2][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:53:29 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 5
Excellent response with high specificity, actionability, and completeness. Minor issue in severity classification and one hypothesis not fully eliminated.
v2zh4.20[Eval][v2][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:53:13 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 5
Strong incident response with concrete evidence and actionable steps; minor issues in specificity (placeholder pod names) and domain correctness (severity misclassification).
v2en4.40[Eval][v2][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:52:59 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 4
Strong response with high specificity and actionability; minor severity misclassification and placeholder sections prevent a perfect score.
v2en4.60[Eval][v2][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:52:45 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and actionability; minor safety and completeness gaps prevent a perfect score.
v2en4.40[Eval][v2][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:52:31 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and actionability; minor gaps in safety (no explicit drain) and completeness (postmortem placeholders).
v1zh4.20[Eval][v1][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:52:17 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with clear root cause identification and actionable steps. Minor improvements in command specificity and timeline completeness would make it excellent.
v1zh5.00[Eval][v1][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:52:03 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 5Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1zh4.20[Eval][v1][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:51:49 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with clear evidence and actionable steps. Minor improvements could include fully copy-pasteable commands and a more detailed rollback plan for the memory limit increase.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:51:35 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1en5.00[Eval][v1][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:51:20 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 5Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1en5.00[Eval][v1][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:51:05 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 5Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v3zh4.60[Eval][v3][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:50:52 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and actionability; minor safety concern and placeholder sections in postmortem prevent a perfect score.
v3zh4.80[Eval][v3][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:50:36 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v3zh4.80[Eval][v3][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:50:22 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v3en4.80[Eval][v3][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:50:08 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v3en4.80[Eval][v3][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:49:53 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v3en5.00[Eval][v3][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:49:38 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 5Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Exemplary incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v2zh4.60[Eval][v2][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:49:25 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with high specificity and actionability; minor safety and completeness gaps prevent a perfect score.
v2zh4.60[Eval][v2][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:49:09 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and actionability; minor safety and completeness gaps prevent a perfect score.
v2zh4.60[Eval][v2][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:48:56 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent incident response with high specificity, actionability, and domain correctness. Minor gaps in safety (missing safer-first alternative for kill query) and completeness (postmortem placeholders).
v2en4.60[Eval][v2][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:48:41 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and actionability; minor safety concern and incomplete postmortem draft prevent a perfect score.
v2en4.80[Eval][v2][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:48:29 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v2en4.80[Eval][v2][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:48:14 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 5Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent response with high specificity, safety, actionability, and domain correctness; minor completeness gaps in postmortem draft place it at 4 rather than 5.
v1zh4.80[Eval][v1][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:47:58 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1zh5.00[Eval][v1][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:47:45 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 5Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1zh4.80[Eval][v1][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:47:29 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:47:15 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:46:59 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, actionability, and domain correctness. Minor safety concern with query killing but mitigated by read-only nature.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:46:45 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v3zh4.00[Eval][v3][zh] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/2/2026, 11:42:30 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 3Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and domain correctness; minor safety and completeness gaps prevent a perfect score.
v3en4.80[Eval][v3][en] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/2/2026, 11:42:11 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety improvement could be adding a safer alternative before increasing DB pool size.
v2zh4.00[Eval][v2][zh] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/2/2026, 11:41:52 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with clear evidence and actionable steps; minor gaps in specificity and safety prevent a perfect score.
v2en4.20[Eval][v2][en] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/2/2026, 11:41:35 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity, safety, and domain correctness; minor gaps in actionability (script details) and completeness (placeholders in postmortem).
v1zh4.60[Eval][v1][zh] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/2/2026, 11:41:20 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 3Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, correctness, and completeness. Minor safety improvement could be adding a safer-first alternative before manual cache warmup.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning6/2/2026, 11:41:05 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety concern with connection pool increase but rollback provided.
v3zh4.20[Eval][v3][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/2/2026, 11:40:49 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high domain correctness and specificity; minor gaps in actionability and completeness due to placeholder fields and missing exact parameters.
v3en4.20[Eval][v3][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/2/2026, 11:40:32 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with clear evidence and actionable steps. Minor improvements could include more precise time ranges in commands and filling postmortem placeholders.
v2zh4.20[Eval][v2][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/2/2026, 11:40:17 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong incident response with clear root cause and actionable steps; minor gaps in command completeness and postmortem fill-ins.
v2en4.20[Eval][v2][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/2/2026, 11:40:05 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong incident response with high specificity and domain correctness; minor gaps in actionability and completeness due to placeholder values and thin sections.
v1zh3.80[Eval][v1][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/2/2026, 11:39:48 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 3Completeness: 4
A solid incident response with good specificity and actionability, but the severity misclassification and a slightly risky mitigation action prevent a higher score.
v1en4.40[Eval][v1][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change6/2/2026, 11:39:36 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
A strong, well-structured incident response with clear root cause analysis and actionable steps. Minor improvements could include filling placeholders and providing hosted zone IDs for full specificity.
v3zh4.80[Eval][v3][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:39:20 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor improvement: consider safer-first alternative before disabling Stripe.
v3en4.80[Eval][v3][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:39:03 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety improvement could be adding safer-first alternatives before destructive changes.
v2zh4.00[Eval][v2][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:38:47 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 3Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and domain correctness; minor gaps in safety (lack of safer-first alternatives) and completeness (placeholder sections).
v2en4.80[Eval][v2][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:38:32 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety quibble but overall outstanding.
v1zh4.20[Eval][v1][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:38:15 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong incident response with high specificity and domain correctness; minor gaps in safety (lack of safer-first alternative) and completeness (postmortem placeholders) prevent a perfect score.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage6/2/2026, 11:38:02 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety improvement possible by adding safer-first alternatives before disabling payment path.
v3zh4.60[Eval][v3][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:37:46 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 5
Excellent response with high specificity, actionability, and completeness; minor safety and domain correctness issues.
v3en4.60[Eval][v3][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:37:32 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 5
Excellent response with high specificity, actionability, and completeness. Minor severity misclassification and safety could be improved with safer-first alternatives.
v2zh4.20[Eval][v2][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:37:18 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 5
Strong response with concrete evidence and actionable steps; minor severity misclassification and lack of safer-first alternatives prevent a perfect score.
v2en4.80[Eval][v2][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:37:04 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor severity misclassification does not detract from overall quality.
v1zh4.80[Eval][v1][zh] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:36:50 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy6/2/2026, 11:36:36 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v3zh4.60[Eval][v3][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:36:22 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and actionability; minor gaps in safety (no safer-first alternative for index) and completeness (placeholders).
v3en4.60[Eval][v3][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:36:08 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, and domain correctness. Minor completeness gaps with placeholders in timeline and thin customer impact.
v2zh5.00[Eval][v2][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:35:53 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 5Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Exemplary incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v2en4.20[Eval][v2][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:35:35 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong incident response with clear root cause identification and actionable steps; minor gaps in specificity of time ranges and incomplete postmortem sections prevent a perfect score.
v1zh4.60[Eval][v1][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:35:16 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent response with high specificity, actionability, and domain correctness. Minor safety and completeness gaps prevent a perfect score.
v1en4.20[Eval][v1][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy6/2/2026, 11:34:58 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with clear root cause, actionable steps, and good safety considerations. Minor improvements could include adding time ranges to commands and expanding customer impact.
v2zh4.40[Eval][v2][zh] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning5/25/2026, 10:24:39 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with strong specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor improvements in command completeness and safer-first alternatives would make it perfect.
v2en4.60[Eval][v2][en] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning5/25/2026, 10:24:19 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent response with high specificity, safety, actionability, and domain correctness; minor gaps in completeness (postmortem placeholders) and safety (no safer-first alternative for code change).
v1zh4.80[Eval][v1][zh] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning5/25/2026, 10:24:01 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety improvement possible by adding a safer-first alternative for cache warmup.
v1en4.40[Eval][v1][en] Cache stampede after Redis key expiry on Black Friday morning5/25/2026, 10:23:42 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
A thorough, well-structured incident response with strong evidence and actionable steps. Minor improvements could include fully copy-pasteable commands and a provided warm-up script.
v2zh4.20[Eval][v2][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change5/25/2026, 10:23:25 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong response with precise root cause and actionable steps; minor gaps in command specificity and timeline completeness.
v2en4.20[Eval][v2][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change5/25/2026, 10:23:08 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong incident response with high specificity and domain correctness; minor gaps in safety (missing pre-revert health check) and completeness (placeholders in postmortem) prevent a perfect score.
v1zh4.20[Eval][v1][zh] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change5/25/2026, 10:22:52 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong incident response with clear root cause analysis and actionable steps. Minor improvements in specificity (time windows) and completeness (filling placeholders) would make it excellent.
v1en4.40[Eval][v1][en] Regional 5xx spike after DNS TTL change5/25/2026, 10:22:38 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
A thorough and well-structured incident response with strong domain correctness and completeness, slightly held back by minor specificity gaps in commands.
v2zh4.20[Eval][v2][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage5/25/2026, 10:22:23 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with clear root cause analysis and actionable steps. Minor gaps in command specificity and postmortem completeness prevent a perfect score.
v2en4.80[Eval][v2][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage5/25/2026, 10:22:08 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness. Minor safety improvement possible by adding safer-first alternatives for thread pool increase.
v1zh4.80[Eval][v1][zh] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage5/25/2026, 10:21:47 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Third-party payment gateway timeouts cascade into checkout outage5/25/2026, 10:21:30 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v2en4.40[Eval][v2][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy5/25/2026, 10:21:06 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 4
Strong response with high specificity and actionability; minor issues in severity classification and postmortem completeness.
v1en5.00[Eval][v1][en] Order service OOM crashloop following v3.7 deploy5/25/2026, 10:20:40 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 5Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v2zh4.60[Eval][v2][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy5/25/2026, 10:20:25 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Excellent response with high specificity, actionability, and domain correctness. Minor safety concern and placeholder gaps prevent a perfect score.
v2en4.60[Eval][v2][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy5/25/2026, 10:20:09 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, detailed incident response with excellent specificity and actionability; minor gaps in safety (no memory check before increasing max_connections) and completeness (placeholders in postmortem).
v1zh4.60[Eval][v1][zh] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy5/25/2026, 10:19:52 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with high specificity and actionability; minor safety concern with database restart and incomplete postmortem placeholders.
v1en4.80[Eval][v1][en] Payment service connection pool exhaustion after batch job deploy5/25/2026, 10:19:38 PM
Specificity: 5Safety: 4Actionability: 5Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 5
Excellent incident response with high specificity, safety, actionability, domain correctness, and completeness.
v2zh4.20payment-svc DB connection storm5/25/2026, 9:07:53 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 4Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
Strong incident response with clear evidence and actionable steps. Minor improvements in specificity and completeness would make it excellent.
v2zh3.80payment-svc DB connection storm5/25/2026, 9:07:46 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 3Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 4Completeness: 4
A strong incident response with concrete evidence and actionable steps, but minor gaps in safety (no safer alternative before terminating connections) and completeness (postmortem placeholders) prevent a perfect score.
v2zh4.00payment-svc DB connection storm5/25/2026, 9:07:39 PM
Specificity: 4Safety: 3Actionability: 4Domain correctness: 5Completeness: 4
A strong, well-structured incident response with clear evidence and actionable steps, though safety could be improved by prioritizing less destructive mitigations.